Search found 35 matches

by benja_m
29 May 2026, 08:53
Forum: Security and Certification
Topic: Will the netload robustness test also be transferred to the ETS?
Replies: 3
Views: 94761

Re: Will the netload robustness test also be transferred to the ETS?

Will the netload robustness test also be transferred to the ETS? Yes, the migration is in our backlog for 2025. What is the status of migration? When will it be transferred to ETS? see https://www.profibus.com/download/profinet-trial-test-and-security-bundle However, as far as i know there are stil...
by benja_m
10 Apr 2026, 12:36
Forum: PROFIprocess
Topic: Acyclic access for pressure value of a PA Profile APL pressure transmitter
Replies: 7
Views: 28327

Re: Acyclic access for pressure value of a PA Profile APL pressure transmitter

I have also tried to access index 0xB00E, "PROCESS VARIABLE" parameter for Analog Input Block as per PA profile which is mandatory according to this standard. Tried slot/subslot 1/1 and 0/1, but in all cases I get nca_unk_if. I wonder whether I am doing something incorrectly or whether th...
by benja_m
10 Apr 2026, 12:32
Forum: Community Stack
Topic: Community Stack Licensing Clarification
Replies: 3
Views: 152799

Re: Community Stack Licensing Clarification

I want to ensure that my intended use of the Profinet Community Stack is allowed under the Community Stack License. I understand it as allowing my company (a PI member company) to use and adapt the code within the Community Stack to create a Profinet adaptation layer for our hardware, then use that...
by benja_m
24 Mar 2026, 15:36
Forum: PROFIprocess
Topic: Acyclic access for pressure value of a PA Profile APL pressure transmitter
Replies: 7
Views: 28327

Re: Acyclic access for pressure value of a PA Profile APL pressure transmitter

Hello PROFINET Forum experts. I have a customer who intends to use a PROFINET controller capable DCS (not a Siemens DCS) to monitor some PROFINET APL devices (pressure transmitters, etc.), in a pretty much plain-vanilla PROFINET over APL application. The devices are of course PA Profile compliant. ...
by benja_m
23 Mar 2026, 08:02
Forum: PROFIprocess
Topic: Acyclic access for pressure value of a PA Profile APL pressure transmitter
Replies: 7
Views: 28327

Re: Acyclic access for pressure value of a PA Profile APL pressure transmitter

Hello PROFINET Forum experts. I have a customer who intends to use a PROFINET controller capable DCS (not a Siemens DCS) to monitor some PROFINET APL devices (pressure transmitters, etc.), in a pretty much plain-vanilla PROFINET over APL application. The devices are of course PA Profile compliant. ...
by benja_m
26 Nov 2025, 13:38
Forum: Getting Started - Automated RT Tester
Topic: Where can I purchase the ETS Board? Also, where can I find the complete list of all required hardware for the tests?
Replies: 1
Views: 15383

Re: Where can I purchase the ETS Board? Also, where can I find the complete list of all required hardware for the tests?

Where can I purchase the ETS Board? Also, where can I find the complete list of all required hardware for the tests? The Test Specification Testspec-PN_2572_V246_Jun25 , which is part of the testbundle, contains all required details about required hardware. Using the mentioned order numbers, you sh...
by benja_m
26 Nov 2025, 13:35
Forum: Getting Started - Automated RT Tester
Topic: Is it mandatory to pass all RT-Tester test cases in order to obtain certification, or are there exceptions?
Replies: 1
Views: 14096

Re: Is it mandatory to pass all RT-Tester test cases in order to obtain certification, or are there exceptions?

The Automated RT Tester provides numerous test cases. Is it mandatory to pass all of them to achieve certification, or are there any exceptions? The tool should skip tests for features not supported by the device. That is okay (although not a pass). You need to pass all testcases that relate to fea...
by benja_m
26 Nov 2025, 13:33
Forum: Specific Test Case Questions
Topic: Has the Test Setup to be changed for some MRP Tests or does the ETS Board be enough?
Replies: 1
Views: 15145

Re: Has the Test Setup to be changed for some MRP Tests or does the ETS Board be enough?

Has the Test Setup to be changed for some MRP Tests or does the ETS Board be enough? Some testcases require a different test setup than others. This is documented in Test specification. In the certification tool, these testcases are bundled in separat folders. You will find ETS Test Setup (the defa...
by benja_m
09 Sep 2025, 07:54
Forum: Specific Test Case Questions
Topic: TEDCheck (CLRPC) test failed
Replies: 3
Views: 30340

Re: TEDCheck (CLRPC) test failed

Hello PROFINET Forum experts. Our equipment is undergoing certification testing. The test results from the certification laboratory using the same version of the test suite are inconsistent with my own test results. The Test tool version information: ART(2.45.0.2), ETS(2.44.4.2). In the certificati...
by benja_m
03 Sep 2025, 13:49
Forum: Specific Test Case Questions
Topic: TEDCheck (CLRPC) test failed
Replies: 3
Views: 30340

Re: TEDCheck (CLRPC) test failed

Hello PROFINET Forum experts. Our equipment is undergoing certification testing. The test results from the certification laboratory using the same version of the test suite are inconsistent with my own test results. The Test tool version information: ART(2.45.0.2), ETS(2.44.4.2). In the certificati...
by benja_m
28 May 2025, 07:53
Forum: Specific Test Case Questions
Topic: MRP Interop - Client (CLRPC) test question
Replies: 4
Views: 119269

Re: MRP Interop - Client (CLRPC) test question

I only had an older TIA-Portal version and was not able to open the delivered projects of test bundle. you can download and install any version of TIA Portal from Siemens free of charge. The download version even provides a 21 day trial license. Doing so will allow you to open (and use) the provide...
by benja_m
26 Feb 2025, 15:29
Forum: Specific Test Case Questions
Topic: IM5_Supported_ETS_ART_2.44.1_Problem
Replies: 5
Views: 80650

Re: IM5_Supported_ETS_ART_2.44.1_Problem

Hello, I'm having this exactly same problem when testing my device, but with the latest ART, version 2.45.0.2. Could it be a regression in test bundle? Does anybody experienced similar issue? Thanks. Yes, i see the same issue (message "According to the GSDML the 'IM5_Supported' is not set to '...
by benja_m
10 Feb 2025, 09:11
Forum: Getting Started - Automated RT Tester
Topic: Setup required to pre-test a two-port PROFINET device with redundancy S2
Replies: 5
Views: 135625

Re: Setup required to pre-test a two-port PROFINET device with redundancy S2

Hi, Of course, that was missing in my GSDML file! Fixed and now all S2 tests are running successfully. Thank you very much. Now my next question refers to MRC Interop - Client test. I guess the setup I would have to put together is the one shown in section 5.2.6.6, figure 5-21. If so, what do I do ...
by benja_m
08 Jan 2025, 08:18
Forum: Miscellaneous
Topic: GSDML Spec, SNMP_FeaturesSupported, "is removed???"
Replies: 7
Views: 145228

Re: GSDML Spec, SNMP_FeaturesSupported, "is removed???"

in clause "8.27.5 CIM_Supported features", that: +-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+- _____"NOTICE: The attribute DCP_FeaturesSupported (o, TokenList, v2.43) is _____removed with v2.44. It is expected that no one has used this attri...
by benja_m
16 Oct 2024, 10:25
Forum: Test Preparation
Topic: Does ETS-Board is necessary for PN pretesting?
Replies: 2
Views: 47954

Re: Does ETS-Board is necessary for PN pretesting?

Hello Team, I want to test my Profinet device before sending it to the certification lab and for that I found the PN test bundle on PI website. The PN specification doc says that, to do the PN pretest we need to use the ETS-Board. Does it necessary to use the ETS-Board or we can use any Profinet IO...
by benja_m
12 Sep 2024, 18:51
Forum: Getting Started - Automated RT Tester
Topic: Help Needed with Pre-Testing Two-Port PROFINET Device Configuration
Replies: 3
Views: 54406

Re: Help Needed with Pre-Testing Two-Port PROFINET Device Configuration

Hi everyone, I am currently pre-testing a two-port PROFINET device before applying for the actual certification in the lab. I am using an ETS board for testing and following the steps outlined in the product documentation. Here is what I have done so far: Set the IP for the NIC connected to the ETS...
by benja_m
23 Jul 2024, 10:42
Forum: PROFINET Implementation
Topic: Switch as Profinet I/O device - LLDP support
Replies: 1
Views: 34849

Re: Switch as Profinet I/O device - LLDP support

We are starting development to support Profinet on our switches. We are aiming for Compliance Class B certification. I am trying to look for what are the LLDP TLVs that are to be supported by the switch acting as a Profinet I/O device. Is there a specification I can refer to similar to the 802.1ab(...
by benja_m
28 May 2024, 10:33
Forum: Process - Certification "How to"
Topic: Profinet certification
Replies: 18
Views: 341019

Re: Profinet certification

vwankhede wrote: 27 May 2024, 11:36 For Profinet certification test with TMDx654IDKEVM eval kit, what drivers and stack needed in TMDx654IDKEVM eval kite?
all you need is contained in the Profinet certification tool. you simply need to "install" a delivered image to an SD card.
by benja_m
17 Apr 2024, 16:45
Forum: Specific Test Case Questions
Topic: IM5_Supported_ETS_ART_2.44.1_Problem
Replies: 5
Views: 80650

Re: IM5_Supported_ETS_ART_2.44.1_Problem

Hello PROFINET Forum experts. I have a couple of problems. For the other I will start another post. This is strange. With ART 2.44.1 we are testing our solution which now supports I&M5 (the previous version didn't so this is the first time I see this.). The ART is telling me that the GSDML file...
by benja_m
09 Apr 2024, 16:44
Forum: PROFINET Implementation
Topic: Specification for BlockQualifier FactoryReset
Replies: 2
Views: 44628

Re: Specification for BlockQualifier FactoryReset

The PN protocol specification (2.4MU4) defines the BlockQualifier field for almost all DCP Suboptions (4.3.1.4.11). But I am missing a definition for the Suboption FactoryReset. Shall the value be ignored by the PN device? In contrast, the BlockQualifier for ResetToFactory is used to select the res...
by benja_m
04 Apr 2024, 12:03
Forum: Test Preparation
Topic: ETS board, flashing system image via ethernet
Replies: 1
Views: 39459

Re: ETS board, flashing system image via ethernet

Hmutlu wrote: 29 Mar 2024, 22:35 Is it possible to flashing system image via ethernet interface?
No, this is not possible. As far as i know, this is a topic on the very long "todo / wish"- list. I miss this functionality as well.
by benja_m
19 Mar 2024, 12:51
Forum: Test Preparation
Topic: ETS for IRT and Netload
Replies: 2
Views: 45253

Re: ETS for IRT and Netload

My understanding is that - for IRT testing I need a different setup using the SPIRTA tool and a separate PCIE-Card - for Netload testing I need different setup using the pinetload tool on a Linux machine Would this be correct so far? Yes, that is correct. I do not know roadmap for those topics. I a...
by benja_m
06 Mar 2024, 07:50
Forum: Specific Test Case Questions
Topic: Non-Profinet-neighbor Testcases with ETS-Board
Replies: 2
Views: 41253

Re: Non-Profinet-neighbor Testcases with ETS-Board

Hello everyone, I have a question about the non-profinet-neighbor test cases with the ETS board (ART tester version 2.44.1.2) If I have understood the test specification correctly, the non-profinet neighbors are simulated. So no additional hardware is required. With the current ART-Tester version, ...
by benja_m
16 Jan 2024, 11:08
Forum: GSDX
Topic: Signing of GSDX file
Replies: 2
Views: 14527

by benja_m
10 Jan 2024, 10:30
Forum: Specific Test Case Questions
Topic: Unexpected LLDP frame from "PROFIBUS" TLV?
Replies: 6
Views: 63325

Re: Unexpected LLDP frame from "PROFIBUS" TLV?

Hello Profinet experts, currently I'm working with a certification tool from ODVA (CT20) to test our Ethernet/IP device. Unforunately it raises an error "Received LLDP frame from unexpected Source MAC Address: 00:0a:cd:2c:ed:aa". I examined this LLDP frame with Wireshark and see some inte...
by benja_m
09 Jan 2024, 14:38
Forum: PROFINET Implementation
Topic: Profinet as a software solution
Replies: 7
Views: 88203

Re: Re:

Is the pi profinet-community-stack a suitable start point for creating a client software implementation on Windows PC? I advise you not to go that way unless you are very experienced with Profinet. The Community Stack is only a pure Protocol stack without dedicated APIs for the application and only...
by benja_m
10 Oct 2023, 13:16
Forum: PROFINET Implementation
Topic: Testing in early development phase
Replies: 5
Views: 70487

Is there a PC-based Profinet master simulator available, or is it preferable to use an HW CPU for this purpose ?​ There are PC based implementations available but i personally do not have experience with it. I am aware of https://profinetcommander.com/ and https://www.codesys.com/ but there may be ...
by benja_m
10 Oct 2023, 07:59
Forum: Process - Certification "How to"
Topic: Profinet certification
Replies: 18
Views: 341019

Re: Profinet certification

Cutter12 wrote: 09 Oct 2023, 16:32 Are there any testing tools available to prepare the device for certification testing ?​

The same tools used by the testlab are available for free to all PI members. You can find the bundle containing the tool here: https://www.profibus.com/download/profinet-test-bundle
by benja_m
10 Oct 2023, 07:58
Forum: Test Preparation
Topic: Required hardware for the certification tests
Replies: 1
Views: 31800

What hardware is required for the certification tests (test bundle) to independently test the device before sending it to the certification lab ?​ This is stated in the test specification. You can find it here https://www.profibus.com/download/profinet-test-specification or as part of the test bund...
by benja_m
09 Oct 2023, 13:19
Forum: PROFINET Implementation
Topic: Memory footprint
Replies: 1
Views: 45397

What is the memory size or footprint of the Profinet RT stack ?​ There is no "the Profinet RT stack". The memory footprint varies between different implementations and their capabilities. There are implementations available which have a very small footprint but may lack some features or s...